ОТЕЧЕСТВЕННЫЕ ШКОЛЬНЫЕ УЧЕБНИКИ О ДРЕВНИХ СЛАВЯНАХ И ИХ ПРОИСХОЖДЕНИИ. ЭТНОГЕНЕЗ СЛАВЯН В ШКОЛЬНОМ КУРСЕ «ИСТОРИИ РОССИИ» Филимоненко Ю.С. Чубур А.А.

! " #$  !" % & ’"                                           %( ) *"

+ ,-

./01234153676 89::3;:<=> ?<=21@3>6 A:41:4B9CD=D3>E AB09F1;:<=> ?<=21@3>6 A:41:4B9CD=D3> GHIJJKE6L9:<B=E66 M5N6O01:D1D:<3;6 B=5E6HP QRRSTUVVWXYVZ[ ?\8A]6\^_6 ‘a88A]Oab\Abcdd GeJeIKE6L9:<B=E6 =f>6gK h15fi=<:N6012=<j336k6 lPgJmHnmgKmKomKK pqrsrtuvwxpNwy6 O92F3:=D96B6F1/=4z6 HKNGeNHeGo i90@=46oe{|e6GfP6 h3F9}0=~3>66 d\6?<=21@3>6 A:41:4B9CD=D3> ggeeeeE6}N6O1DC=E66 M5N6^10@9D49B=E6I .:5N6F1/N65N6GK h30=6Jee6<CN66 =<=C6L a6HeGofGG

¡

¢£⁄¥ƒ§¤£'¥“

«‹›fifl›–›‹†‡·¶fl•‚

 „”»…‰ ¿» …» `´´ˆ˜¯„

˘˙†¨˚¸˝˛†ˇ—†˝—˙†ˇ†

›««fl†

YZ[\]^_‘\]^ab cdefghi^jklm nYop_q_r

                                                                          “ '¥¥ Æ' 'ª                                        ¥ §                    ŁØŒŁº

˘˙†˙˛˙¸ˇ†˙¸—ˇ†˝˙—†˛˝˙—††˝†—ˇ˙†æææ¸˝˙¸˚

                                                                  ı łøœß ıß                                           )*+,-.

                                                                                                                          œ                   œ œ                            /012304œ567839:8œ;<==03œ

œ >690:?œ@0?6AB:?œ397œC<D40=26? œ œ E3B3403œ>B<1:83

                                                                  ß ı ıœ                                                F@GHI;GJ5œKIJ;@

                                                                                                                                    œı œß                                           J93B:4LœM<?N39:8œ;<==03

ß œ œß            /012304œ;:O39BN:8œ;<==03  œœ!  P3469B093œ@08:A23œQ1?3096  œœı       R3?901œM:A23?L39œJ?O6903

"œœ#"$ S:TA06A2œ>4:O=10œC:4397 œœ% U<?0œI=01œM3N312=B39 ı" œ&œı’ ( V310?œJ4068œJN6?D30T39

WX

/0 ) 1 \2/

                                                                    !                         "# $ %

                                                                       &                  ’                                        (

)*+*,-./.0-1""23435""

6789:;<=>?@:ABC7:DEF99G=>A9<EF7:<DFD><HI>C;CBFH<;C>JIKI>LFD7@E:;@?@M>6789:;M>> NOPQRST>USRVWXSRYZPQRSI[VP

\]^_‘a‘a_bcd]‘efdghijkb‘lmbcnd]‘dl_^oe]polbodflqbg‘rdfhkdmlbokdgd]]hmkbll‘slq‘m tqb_u]hmvrdw]‘q^m‘lfbk‘‘xoq_yr^evrdw]‘qf^q]^aho^dgbsi]bobs_‘]‘‘pz{bq^a^_|rfb‘gdy}‘dle o]^lfbe}ddokdge{blbw‘eo{b_]bsgdkdn^]]vyfdgv]dbfk^c^yf|^bfr^lf‘]dlvfbt‘wbr]hd|vlf^kdo~ t‘d‘]dfbr]hdlodnd]‘e{bn^]]bs{kbw_dgd^‘wb_ddw_‘abqqkdqbgd]nbo^]]hgdndk^_u]hgblvn^k~ lfod]]hglf^]n^kfbgbwk^abo^]‘en‘n^qf‘rdlq‘gdn‘]‘^gvrdw]‘q|lban^]]hsqb__dqf‘obg‘lfbk‘qbo {bnkvqbobnlfobg ^]d_‘]^|]b‘b]]do{b_]bsgdkd‘mbfk^c^df^]]bd‘ll_dnbo^]‘dd}dk^a{bq^~ aho^df|rfblban^]‘db{f‘g^_u]bbtqb_u]bbvrdw]‘q^{b‘lfbk‘‘bll‘‘blf^dflend_bgwvnv}db ]dg gbvf‘nb_c]hwhfu‘l{b_uabo^]h{ba‘f‘o]hdr^lf‘oldm{dkdr‘l_d]]hm{blbw‘s

+ / /+- .-/./+ .20-+. 5-5,,20-+. 3/4.*0*-5**

¡¢ £⁄¥ƒƒ¥ ¥¢§ ¥⁄ ⁄

                             ¥¤¥⁄                                         ƒ ƒ'⁄" ⁄'⁄                                           ¥¤ ⁄¥

§ƒ ’ ƒ“ «ƒ§ ¥(

«‹›‹fifl–†fl‡""2·¶•¥"¥"

‚„”Q»…‰>¿Q¿N>»R`N„…R¿”>´[QˆNPR[RQ»>˜I>¯N¿„V`…‰”M>‚„”Q»…‰M>NOPQRST>USRVWXSRYZPQRSI[VP

˘˙¨˚¸¸˝˛ˇ—ˇ— i ˙˝˛ˇ— ¨¸p˙ˇ—˝ ˇ¨˙ ˝ ˙ ¸¸¨˙—¸ˇ˝˚¸—˝˝ˇˇ˝˝¸ x˙ ˙ˇ—¸˝¨ i˙Æ˙pz—¨¸¸—˝Æ˙ˇ—¨ˇˇ— ˙ˇ˚¨¨¨ ¨˙ˇ˛˚ˇ—¸ ˇ˝˙˝ˇªˇ¨˙ ¨ ¨ˇ˚ ˝˙˝¸|˝ˇ¨ˇ¨˙˙¨ ¨ˇ˙˛˝¨ˇ˝˙˝˙ˇ—¸¨ˇˇ — ˝¸ˇ˝¸ˇ˝ˇ— ¨ˇ˙ˇ¸˝˛ˇ— ¨ˇ¨ˇ ¨ˇ˝˙¨ˇ¨˙¨ ¸ˇˇ˝¨ ¨ˇ ˚¨ˇ¨ ˙ ˇ— ¨ ¸—˝˛ Ł¨˙˙|ˇ¨¸˝˝¸

˙˝ˇ˛˚ªˇˇ— —¸¸ˇ˚˝˙¨¨˙¸—˝Æ¸ˇ—¨ˇˇ— ¨ˇ˝˙˝˛¨˙˝ˇ¨¸—˝˝ˇˇ˝˝˝˙ˇ——¸ˇ˝˚

˝˛ ¸¸¨¸¨¨ˇˇ˝˛ˇ—˛ˇ Ø˙ˇ—˙Æˇˇ˝˝˝˛ˇ—¸ ¸¸˛¨ˇ—¸ ˙Œˇ¸¨˙¨˙¸—˝ ¸

£–ºfl• › –æ·fl––‹2••‹›fi2·flfl›·‹æfl•ºæ–æ¶flfl†

ıłøœßœ œœ łœßœø ]blf‘p f‘g‘lrdk{ho^dflelycdfbw ‘m{kb‘lmbcnd]‘‘j_dgd]]hdlbyah qb]^Øfhlerd_df‘e]^tdskh|lb_^l~

n]^‘aq_yrdohm{kbw_dg‘lfbk‘‘ ]bfdqlfvvrdw]‘q^lv}dlfovyfofd~

blfbr]bsokb{h‘|lbbfodflfod]]b{k^‘~rd]‘doldbfbbfhlerd_df‘e df]‘ lfbk‘‘bll‘‘ fb{kbw_dg^l_^oe]lqbb l_bo^bw^]f^m|lq_^o‘]^m|od]df^m ^fb f]bd]da^ n^]]bslf^fud{kdn{k‘]ef^ ql_^oe]^gbq^aho^dfle]dbwbl]bo^]]b {b{hfq^k^llgbfkdfublbwd]]blf‘{kd{bn^~{k‘{‘l^]]hgf^qbdlb‘bqv_ufvk]bdbw~ o^]‘efbsfdghoqvkld‘lfbk‘‘olkdn]ds k^abo^]‘d|q^qiblup‘_‘ivlup|{k‘~ tqb_d]^bl]bodqbg{^k^f‘o]bb^]^_‘a^ rdgq^qofkvn^m!\ hw^qbo^xofdbnh vrdw]bs_‘fdk^fvkh ]d{kdkdq^dgbb^ofbk‘fdf^on^]]bsbw~

‘l{b_uabo^otdgleolbodflq‘mtqb~_^lf‘zfbeqbwhil_^oe]lqbd{_dgep _^mvrdw]‘qdilfbk‘‘ pn_eq_^l~xqb]fd]f^]^_‘aoblfbr]hm‘lfbr]‘qbo l^|{efhs{^k^k^d_‘qbg{bloe}d]vwdn‘fd_u]bnbq^aho^df]dfbcndlfod]~ nkdo]‘gl_^oe]^g| dlgbfke]blfukvl‘‘l_^oe] zfdkk‘fbk‘^_u~ ]^vwbvyllbokdgd]]bsfbrq‘akd]‘e{b~]b{k‘oea^]bqkblu]^]d{kbolqbg

_‘k^‘y‘]^‘a_‘t]yy^q^ndg‘r]blfu {k^obwdkdcudi"d]fkbgbn]bb‘a{_d~ ‘lqvnblfu‘__ylfk^‘s|l_dnvdf{k‘~gd]]hmlbyaboeo‘_blu{_dgekblu|‘_‘ a]^fu|rfbfdqlfvrdw]‘q^obl]bo]bgoh~kvlu|{kbc‘o^otddonkdo]blf‘]^kdqd odkd]q^qlfbrq‘akd]‘eoa_enbo{dk‘bn^ blux{k‘fbq]d{k^|]‘cd‘do^z|jba~ dblban^]‘e‘lblfbkb]h{dn^b‘rdlqbb cd]^ao^]‘dfbb{_dgd]‘k^l{kblfk^]‘~ kdgdl_^ fgdf‘g]dqbfbkhd]dnblf^fq‘ _blu]^oldmoblfbr]hml_^oe]|qbfbkhm b{dkohm|l^g^{kbw_dg^l_^oe]~lf^_‘]^aho^fukvl^g‘|^fdkk‘fbk‘y|]^

lqbbf]bd]da^]da^fkb]vf^ _^oe]d qbfbkbsb]‘c‘_‘|vllqbsadg_ds‘_‘ onkv{beo_eyfleq^qi¨—˙pvluyp _vw‘]hodqbobfbno‘]vfb{b~ q^aho^dfle|b]‘ic‘ovfookb{dlnkdo~_ynud|okd^_u]blf‘oodnd]]bdq‘dolq‘g‘

#$\ %&$\’( j #)\’* !\ \+,|-.

9@                                            [\]J^LPNJYOQ^YJMKYM^_[

                                                                !

!"                                                                                         #

!                                                                      $

 %                                                                             &

 ! ’ "

 !               %

                                                                   "

&( )"

$

 &

  (            %            &

 !                                                         % 

           * & & !

+                                           +                   ,

*      -                                              

*      !%           $

#& & & %                                                          

                +             $             .!

                                                                   / #

                                              &                      %$

& % 0 !   !  0 #

                                 0                                  

&  &  & #$            

   0 !                      *

0 &                                                                              1 & &

)&1$ ) )&1$

                            &1$!                                    

0                          !                                           !

’           ’ 

0 /                                                                         &

                                            0 +                               

 ! ! & & "& " &%

                )                                                                       2 %

                            "                                            )&

+  $                                                                &

                            )                          )

 )        ’  +!        3                             

" .                                                                 !                      *

4 &                           2                  

!                          &                    56&789:

’                                                                                            !

+      " ;   <=$! 5>?:2            

                                                                                 &

                                                                             )

#!=                            &                                                5>?&

7>@:&                                !

/                                                                                             !

                                              "                                           +!

                      A                    B&

 !            

% &

# & #

                                +                                        &C

&                                                          5>>:

0                                                                          

& " +     &

"  &        D+

                                     "                                            

                0                          E                   

                                                   %

! &

#                           ( &            & &       = &

& "               5>?& 7>F:(          !

G0 # / (

A

/        B$           !             

                               (                                         !

5>?&7>H:$

+ ! %

                &                                     %

              0                                             ! !

                                                                                             &

 ) + &     )              & 

!

                          ! IIJ ! +

       *      &

J

 & + !A !B%"

! &

                                  &                                                   & )"

!

JKLMNKOLJPKOQRPSNKOQPTMUVMNJWMKLOQMXSYOLJPKZ>>&8?>@

                                                         UVR &"RW17R1 K7RXU                                                LM

                              !                                     "

# ! $!

$                                      %

&                                                       !

                                                                                              #

                                                                                               ’

                                 ()*" !+                              

# ,                                                                                          !

                                & ! %     ..///

0                                1 ,

!

 ! 2 # $      !

! + .        3()456*7 3

# 8 9       ! 2           !

!,+ #                                                           8

                         -7                                                                 :

& ;                                                 , ,

                    3                               < $

! , 8=

                                                                                              2

# !             , , ,#

,           !              $                            , !            !

                                   ’ $%                       

   +

!          !  - ! !

                                                ,

<                                              3

                                                                                              $

,8

! 2

                               ! :>                                      $

! $ 2 +!  3 = ’# $

?                                       !

                                  ,+                                    

$@ 7                           0                                             A (B*

                                      0>A                        (5*

# , $ C $  A ! ! ,! 8<

$

,

,+             # ! $       !

                                            # !                       

                                            ! $ <                                          !

 # +         D

#                              !                         2=

# 3 ,2!                                                                               ! +

$ ! !A ! % 2 !

!                                 :#                                           

 ! !                  8

&     !              , 2! 1      2!

!                                                  # #    6

             !                                              #

                                  $                                #

 ,+ %                                                 %

%                                                                          

#                               %33                              ,

$ 9                                                         $ #

                  $                                     $ 2

$ !                                                                  3 #

                                     !                                           $

!                                                                    $

!

!                                                                                        ? +

, 2! !+ !

3 $%                                                                $

                                                                                          < C

& #                                                                         #

E $                                         <                                  

                              !                                         $

!

$                                                                      (F*

G !                                         

# HI)F$  $

                                       $                                       ’

(J*                                                               #

 #                                            $

                          ,#                              !? $

                                                                                 $ 8CA 3

             !                                          +

                           ,                       !

%

                  ?                               !

E                                         C

$ 2                                              #                                        !

> K

                                                 2

"                                                             +

$                                                                                          2

%                                                !                                         ,

% 2

                                                                                           # !

! $3 $

                             !                    !

"                        !F

N1O’K "&’PQOK" @D7A1"RN1 @S&9&&G"E&0 R>T))HI)F

Z^                                                qrs3tcge3ofhto3dbodtuq

                              !"#                            $

                               %&                          ’

()*             ’               + , . /’    ’

                                             0                                             %

% 1 23   % 1 1

                                +                           ’!

                                                          ’                             

, .           ’ 4

                                  ’                     

4      !0            ,               ’

5      ’

, ’ ’

6      + ’ 1 4 4 7 %

1 (8*

9                                                     , %  ,

0         1 3 , ’%, 1

1         1              .

(:)*9

                         ’                                                                ’ %

                              ,                            %               

                                          +                         

- ;                                                                 , 4

9 ’

/               

% #1 < %

                                        ’ %                                -

                                       /                                             ’ % %

                       ’                                            ’

1                                                     1 <                                 ’

;                                        %

                                                             ,

                                                                                   1

                                                   + 1                                     1

’

=                                 .

                                              % .4                                        1

% 1                                       %                                      

1 %         +

>                                                            

                          %’                                  1

                           !                                          % .

                                             1 +                                    

                                  %                 ">

                          1                                                        +?23$

23 @A!6"B                                                  1

                          "< ’                                  1 $

                                     #                  ’                                    1

1C D

D                                  1    =

E                                   % %4

                                1                           1

                          $(F*C                                            %

- ’

%4

%    1 +                G

%                                             H

>                    % 1 % 1 %1

"< 1                                              $                   6

                              ’                    %

0 % 4     .4 4         %           

                             .                                                                 .

% G ’ .

                  ’                        ’                                           

                          ’                                   ’                   %

           %                                                   ’ % ’

% 1                                                              +

’           1 %

=                                        ’                                                   ’

’                                  ’

                                               ,                                              4

 1

%	’
#G>	%
	41                             %
-	’
4	+ 1
I ’	’ & ’

                            -                                                              41

                   4                                                                        >

JKLMNOPQLRSTURVTW

:C                                   >                                                      1

X +?23 Y 6 % %4 %

                                                                       ,

0) 0G6< 4 FA::08Z

F[                              ;;                                                1 ;; #1 ;;

G                         \ %                       ] >

Y G                                           %                                     0G6>

’ "9##<]$FAA^

)>                                           6Y 6 %                                   41

%4 %                             ’1                           _< 7

5=/                            >G5%                           ‘ %4

+                                                                   0G6;

-FAA80F^^

@>                                         6Y 6 %                                   41

%4 % ’1 + ;F a:_ G ’ C <H#-

3bcdebfc3gbfhigjebfhgkd?lde3mdbcfhdnjofc3gbp::FA:Y

                                                            bcD#SEDd-#D-1FDeb                                                    G

                     ! "#                      $

% & %’ ( )(*+’% #, - *( . .

/ 0/!12,’ ! /(%

34 /%*/566789:;<=>? @                                                    /A

B C

C1’                                                                         "!,), # D% (

###EF’,                                          , (C 6 *

GC # C

                  %4                          66# (                                  %

H% ) %’ ! I %6 , !

1D %)JD %%% (                                                                 (E1

             K                        + %$ (                                       #L#*

M L &M#NC

GE+, O *+’%                                                    4 (

1 G

                           #4 1D% (E                                              !$4

/                          &APQ                                                  F’, (,

,* % I+4’K ! *

,%

R/ H%/ )’ ! I

)(*+ .4% / ( S1 ,’T . * % % % I

# .

              U                                                           - VI( 1 W# (X

W +XQA ’ A                                                              % I+! %%

 *W %’+4X %’ 66E !,

#,                        ’+4%                                                 ( +! %Y

% ’ )Z I%%O( )) %

) %%/ / DV % ) O(    #

N[                                OEK                        ( D* %

\ % % % )

#%%/#% %+ %%Z+ #,1% GGC # .C

-]\F1ES\1^_]FE1"H#-ED-1 "‘1SVSSOE2S 1Da

Краткое описание документа:

Статья написана совместно мной и моей ученицей в процессе работы над ее дипломом. Одна из ключевых проблем истории Восточной Европы и, соответственно праистории России – это проблема славянского этногенеза. В данной статье предпринята попытка рассмотреть особенности преподавания этой темы в курсе истории в средней школе на основе компаративного анализа учебной литературы.